Is Soybean Oil Comedogenic?
Soybean oil is one of the most common oils in skincare, and one of the most confusing. It shows up in drugstore moisturizers, body lotions, oil cleansers, and massage oils, usually under its INCI name, Glycine Soja Oil. It is cheap, rich in linoleic acid, and often described as light. So why do most charts list it at 3 out of 5, and some at 4 to 5?
On this site, soybean oil is rated 3 out of 5, and the honest answer is a range, not a single number.
In This Article
- Quick Answer
- What Soybean Oil Actually Is
- Its Comedogenic Rating, Explained
- The Linoleic Paradox
- Why the Rating Varies So Much
- The Fungal Acne Note
- Where It Works Best
- Who Should Be Careful
- Soybean Oil vs Other Common Oils
- 5 Common Mistakes
- How to Use Soybean Oil
- How to Check Your Own Products
- Frequently Asked Questions
- The Bottom Line
Quick Answer
Soybean oil is rated 3 out of 5 on this site, the most commonly cited value across comedogenicity charts. That puts it in the moderate band: a poor first pick as a pure face oil for oily or acne prone skin.
Sources list soybean oil anywhere from 2 to 5. The 3 comes from Fulton’s original 1989 testing and from careful modern guides, including Herbal Dynamics, NicerSkin, and Typology. The 4 to 5 end comes from older charts, the 2 to 3 end from supplier sources. Plan around 3. A rating describes one ingredient, not a finished product.
What Soybean Oil Actually Is
Soybean oil is pressed from soybeans, Glycine max. On ingredient lists it appears as Glycine Soja (Soybean) Oil, Soybean Oil, or Soja Oil. It is pale yellow, mild smelling, and inexpensive, which is why formulators use it widely.
The fatty acid profile is what makes the rating surprising: about 50 to 55 percent linoleic acid, about 20 to 25 percent oleic acid, about 10 percent palmitic acid, and about 7 percent alpha-linolenic acid, plus vitamin E, phytosterols, and isoflavones (genistein and daidzein). On paper, that looks like a light, skin friendly oil. The rating says otherwise.
Its Comedogenic Rating, Explained
The 0 to 5 scale traces back to James Fulton’s 1989 rabbit ear testing. Ingredients were applied to rabbit ears and graded on comedones formed. Soybean oil scored 3 for comedogenicity and 0 for irritancy.
| Source type | Rating given | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Fulton 1989, original rabbit ear testing | 3 | Direct testing, comedogenicity 3, irritancy 0 |
| Modern guides (Herbal Dynamics, NicerSkin, Typology) | 3 | Fulton derived charts, moderate band |
| Acne focused brands (CLEARSTEM, UseAcneSafe) | 3 to 4 | Fulton derived, caution for acne prone skin |
| Older charts (Misumi, earlier Herbal Dynamics page) | 4 to 5 | Fulton derived tables, “very dry, best for body use” |
| Supplier and formulator sources (Accio) | 2 to 3 | Fatty acid profile and typical use concentration |
| Low quality beauty blogs | 0 to 1 | Marketing claims, not credible |
No number in that table is a lab measured fact about your bottle. The ratings trace back to 1980s testing, and no single validated scale assigns every oil a dependable breakout probability. A rating of 3 is a strong caution, not a guarantee of breakouts.
A few blogs claim soybean oil is rated 0 to 1 and “non-comedogenic for all skin types.” That contradicts Fulton, every serious chart, and the oil’s own heavy feel. Plan around the middle to high end of the range.
The Linoleic Paradox
High linoleic oils are usually the light, low rated ones. Sunflower oil is about 65 percent linoleic acid and rated 0. Grapeseed oil is about 70 percent linoleic acid and rated 1. Soybean oil is about 50 to 55 percent linoleic acid, so by the fatty acid logic alone, it should be rated 1 or 2. It is rated 3. Why?
First, the rating did not come from the fatty acid profile. It came from rabbit ear testing, which measures what actually happened on rabbit skin, not what a chemist would predict from the composition. The test used the neat oil, applied repeatedly, under occlusion, on skin far more reactive than human facial skin. That method overstates risk for humans, but it also captures something the fatty acid numbers miss: how an oil actually behaves on skin.
Second, soybean oil is not only linoleic acid. About 20 to 25 percent oleic acid, about 10 percent palmitic acid, and about 7 percent alpha-linolenic acid round out the blend. Oleic acid is heavier and slower to absorb, and palmitic acid adds body, so the oil feels noticeably heavier than sunflower or grapeseed oil. A 50 percent linoleic oil with a heavy remainder is not the same as a 70 percent linoleic oil.
Third, soybean oil oxidizes easily. Its high polyunsaturated content makes it go rancid faster than more stable oils, especially in a clear bottle kept in a warm bathroom. Oxidized oils feel stickier, smell off, and irritate more readily. Refinement matters too: refined oil is more stable, while unrefined oil oxidizes faster. Charts rarely say which version they tested, and high oleic soybean varieties bred for cooking oil add another variable the charts do not distinguish.
The chemistry says soybean oil has a good fatty acid profile. The rating says that in practice it behaves like a moderate, fairly heavy oil. Trust the behavior.
Why the Rating Varies So Much
The 2 to 5 spread reflects what each source measures: Fulton tested neat oil on rabbit ears, modern guides copy Fulton or average several charts, and supplier sources rate the oil as used in formulas, usually at low concentrations.
Concentration changes everything. A 2006 study by Draelos and DiNardo in the Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology found that finished cosmetics containing ingredients previously identified as comedogenic were not necessarily comedogenic. Soybean oil at 2 percent in a moisturizer is a different proposition from pure soybean oil on the face every night. Most charts rate the neat oil, not the finished product.
Skin type changes the answer too, and marketing pressure pushes numbers down: a cheap oil rated 3 to 5 is a harder sell than one rated 0 to 1. When you see soybean oil rated 0 to 1 with no discussion of Fulton or fatty acids, you are reading marketing, not evidence.
The Fungal Acne Note
Fungal acne is driven by Malassezia yeast, which feeds on fatty acids in the C11 to C24 range. Soybean oil’s main fatty acids, linoleic acid (C18:2), oleic acid (C18:1), and palmitic acid (C16:0), all sit inside that range. Soybean oil is therefore not a recommended face oil for fungal acne.
High linoleic content does not make an oil safe for fungal acne, because Malassezia can use linoleic acid too. Safer oils are those with fatty acids outside the range Malassezia feeds on, such as squalane and MCT oil. Our guide to what fungal acne is explains how to judge a product properly.
Where It Works Best
For body care, soybean oil is a genuinely good ingredient. Body skin is thicker and less breakout prone, and a body lotion built on it softens dry elbows, knees, and shins well. The rating matters far less below the neck.
For very dry skin, it can work on the face in small amounts, and for hair it smooths frizz and softens dry ends. For massage, it is a classic carrier oil. None of these uses asks the oil to sit on acne prone facial skin all night, which is where the rating bites.
Who Should Be Careful
If your skin is oily or acne prone, soybean oil is a poor first pick as a pure face oil. A 3 rating, a heavy feel, and easy oxidation is exactly the profile acne prone readers do worst with. Lighter oils cost little more: sunflower at 0, grapeseed at 1, rosehip at 1, and jojoba at 2.
Managing fungal acne? Soybean oil is generally not recommended as a face oil. If you use oil cleansers, check the base oil: a cleanser that leaves a heavy residue on acne prone skin can cause congestion even though it rinses off. Sunflower or grapeseed oil cleansers are the safer default.
If a product lists soybean oil near the top and you break out from it, do not blame the brand first. Near the top, it is doing the main work; near the end, it is a supporting ingredient.
Soybean Oil vs Other Common Oils
| Ingredient | Comedogenic rating | Feel on skin | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Soybean oil | 3 | Moderately heavy, slow absorbing | Body, very dry skin, hair |
| Sunflower oil | 0 | Light, fast absorbing | Oily and acne prone skin |
| Grapeseed oil | 1 | Very light, dry finish | Oily and acne prone skin |
| Rosehip oil | 1 | Light to medium, dry finish | Face use, dull or uneven skin |
| Jojoba oil | 2 | Light, waxy | Face use, balancing oily skin |
| Marula oil | 3 | Rich, slow absorbing, soft sheen | Very dry and mature skin, hair, body |
| Coconut oil | 4 | Rich, greasy | Body only for most acne prone people |
Sunflower at 0 is the safer face choice at about the same price, marula at 3 is the luxury equivalent, and coconut at 4 is heavier still.
5 Common Mistakes People Make With Soybean Oil
1. Believing the lowest rating on the internet. Soybean oil is listed anywhere from 0 to 5, and the 0 to 1 comes from marketing led pages. Plan around 3.
2. Assuming high linoleic means non-comedogenic. Linoleic acid helps, but it is not the whole story: 50 to 55 percent linoleic acid, rated 3.
3. Using it as a pure face oil on oily or acne prone skin. It costs almost nothing, which makes it tempting. Lighter oils cost little more and suit oily skin far better.
4. Judging a blend by one ingredient. A moisturizer with soybean oil near the end of the list is not a 3 rated product. The blend decides, so check the whole list.
5. Keeping an old bottle past its best. Soybean oil oxidizes fast. A rancid bottle smells off and irritates more readily. Store it cool and dark.
How to Use Soybean Oil
For body use, apply it freely on damp skin after a shower. For the face, very dry skin only: 2 to 3 drops, warmed between your palms, pressed into damp skin after cleansing. For hair, smooth a small amount over dry ends, not the scalp, if you are acne prone.
Patch test on one cheek or jawline for 5 to 7 days first. Store the bottle cool and dark, and buy small bottles.
How to Check Your Own Products
Look for Glycine Soja Oil, Soybean Oil, or Soja Oil on the label, and note its position: near the top it is doing the main work, near the end it is a supporting ingredient.
Paste the full ingredient list into the free Pore-Clogging Checker and it will flag every ingredient with a pore clogging risk. New congestion? Our guide to signs your skincare is clogging your pores and the closed comedones guide can help you trace it. For the full reference, see the pore-clogging ingredients list and the oils hub, and read what comedogenic means to understand the scale.
Check Your Product Before You Trust One Ingredient
Soybean oil is rated 3, but your product is a whole formula. Paste the full ingredient list into the free Pore-Clogging Checker and see every pore clogging risk in seconds.
Check My Ingredients FreeFrequently Asked Questions
No. The most cited rating is 3 out of 5. A few blogs claim 0 to 1, but that contradicts Fulton’s testing and every serious chart.
Very dry skin: yes, 2 to 3 drops at a time. Oily or acne prone skin: not daily as a pure face oil. Body use: daily is fine.
Generally no, not as a face oil. Its main fatty acids all fall in the C11 to C24 range Malassezia yeast can feed on.
It depends on concentration and the formula. Low on the ingredient list of a well formulated moisturizer, it is unlikely to cause breakouts on its own. Near the top, or as a pure oil, it carries its full 3 rating.
The Bottom Line
Soybean oil earns its 3 honestly: a moderately heavy, affordable oil with a good fatty acid profile that still behaves like a middle of the scale oil on skin. Its rating is genuinely disputed, from 2 to 5, with 3 as the most cited value.
The high linoleic content does not rescue it, the rating comes from real testing rather than chemistry predictions, and it says nothing about the rest of a blend. Very dry skin: use it on the body freely, and on the face in small amounts if your skin tolerates it. Oily, acne prone, or fungal acne prone skin: buy a lighter oil instead, and keep soybean oil for your body and hair.
This is the last of the original 8 ingredient oils. The full oil cluster now runs from sunflower at 0 to coconut at 4, and soybean oil at 3 fills the moderate middle beside marula.
This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. If breakouts persist or worsen, consult a qualified dermatologist.