What Does Comedogenic Mean?
It is printed on almost every bottle aimed at acne prone skin, quoted in every ingredient list, and used to rank everything from face oils to foundations. Yet most people who have read the word “comedogenic” have never been told what it actually means, where the numbers behind it come from, or how much trust the word deserves. This article answers all three questions, in plain language.
Short version: comedogenic describes something that tends to clog pores and form comedones, the blackheads and whiteheads that can come before acne. The 0 to 5 scale you see quoted everywhere is a real system with a real history, but it is older and less certain than the confident numbers suggest. Used carefully, it is a useful guide. Used as a verdict, it misleads.
In This Article
- Quick Answer
- What Comedogenic Means, in Plain Words
- The 0 to 5 Comedogenic Scale
- Where the Numbers Come From
- What the Ratings Can and Cannot Tell You
- What “Non-Comedogenic” on a Label Really Means
- How to Read a Label Like a Checker
- 5 Common Mistakes People Make With Comedogenic Ratings
- How to Check Your Own Products
- Frequently Asked Questions
- The Bottom Line
Quick Answer
Comedogenic means likely to clog pores and form comedones. A comedo is a plugged hair follicle. When it stays open at the surface it shows as a blackhead, and when it closes over it shows as a whitehead. An ingredient is called comedogenic when it has a tendency to cause that plugging.
The 0 to 5 scale ranks that tendency: 0 means no significant pore clogging in the test, 1 means very low, 2 to 3 means borderline, and 4 to 5 means a clear, reproducible clogging effect. The numbers come from tests done in the 1970s and 1980s, mostly on rabbit ears, and they describe single ingredients at high concentration, not finished products on your face. A rating is a starting point for choosing products, not a promise about how your skin will respond.
“Non-comedogenic” on a bottle is a claim, not a certification. No regulator defines the word or requires a standard test behind it, so brands apply it themselves. The honest way to use the word is to check the full ingredient list, which is exactly what the free checker on this site does.
What Comedogenic Means, in Plain Words
The word comes from “comedo”, the dermatological name for a plugged hair follicle. The plural is comedones. Every pore on your face is the opening of a hair follicle, and inside each follicle a sebaceous gland produces sebum, the oil that keeps skin supple. Normally sebum flows out freely, carrying dead skin cells with it. When that flow is blocked, sebum and dead cells collect inside the follicle and form a plug.
There are two kinds, and you already know them by sight. An open comedo is a blackhead: the plug sits open at the surface, and its dark colour comes from the oxidation of lipids when they meet air, not from dirt. A closed comedo is a whitehead: the plug sits under a thin layer of skin, so it looks like a small pale bump. Both can stay quiet or become inflamed and turn into the red breakouts people call acne.
So when an ingredient is described as comedogenic, the claim is specific: it has a tendency to encourage that plugging. It does not mean the ingredient is dirty, toxic, or bad for everyone. It means that, in the conditions it was tested in, it increased follicular plugging enough to be noticed. How much that matters for your skin depends on the ingredient, how much of it is in the product, what else is in the product, and how your skin behaves.
It also helps to separate comedogenicity from two things people often confuse it with. The first is irritation. An ingredient can irritate skin without clogging pores, and irritation itself can trigger breakouts, so a product can be a problem without being comedogenic. The second is purging. Purging happens when an active ingredient speeds up skin cell turnover and brings existing congestion to the surface faster, and it is temporary. A comedogenic ingredient does the opposite job: it physically helps block the pore. Our guide to signs your skincare is clogging your pores can help you tell the difference.
The 0 to 5 Comedogenic Scale
Most ingredient charts you will find online use the same 0 to 5 scale. Each ingredient gets a single number, read like this. The examples below use ratings from this site’s own guides and rating tables.
| Rating | What it means | How to use it | Examples from this site |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | Will not clog pores; no significant plugging in the test | Lowest risk; fine for most acne prone skin | Mineral oil 0 |
| 1 | Very low likelihood of clogging pores | Low risk; usually fine, check the rest of the formula | Grapeseed oil 1, rosehip oil 1, dimethicone 1 |
| 2 | Moderately low; some acne prone skin may react | Low to middle risk; fine in most formulas, watch position on the label | Sweet almond oil 2, cetearyl alcohol 2 |
| 3 | Moderate; noticeable pore clogging potential | Middle risk; check the formula and the ingredient’s position carefully | Cetearyl octanoate 3, from the alcohols hub table |
| 4 | Fairly high; likely to clog pores for many acne prone people | High risk for leave on face products; better suited to body use | Coconut oil 4, cocoa butter 4 |
| 5 | High likelihood of clogging pores | Highest risk; avoid near the top of leave on face products | Isopropyl myristate 5, isopropyl palmitate 5, wheat germ oil 5 |
A few honest notes about this table. First, different charts disagree on some ingredients, and that disagreement is information, not a mistake to hide. Shea butter, for example, is listed anywhere from 0 to 2 depending on the source, because the rating changes with how the butter is processed and what it is mixed into. Second, the scale is best read in bands rather than single points: 0 to 1 is generally treated as low risk, 2 to 3 as borderline, and 4 to 5 as high risk. That is how the original researchers themselves read it. Third, the examples at 5, like isopropyl myristate, are esters and solvents used for slip and spreadability, not oils.
Our guide to how the comedogenic scale works explains each band in more detail, and the full pore-clogging ingredients list collects the site’s ratings in one place.
Where the Numbers Come From
The numbers look precise, and that precision is part of their appeal. But they come from a specific place and time, and knowing that place and time changes how you should read them.
Chapter one: the problem gets a name, 1972. Dermatologists Albert Kligman and Otto Mills published a paper called “Acne cosmetica” in the Archives of Dermatology in 1972. They described a pattern they were seeing in patients: persistent, low grade acne caused by cosmetic products, especially in women using heavy creams and foundations. Until then, nobody had a proper word for cosmetics causing comedones. That name is why the word comedogenic exists in skincare at all.
Chapter two: the rabbit ear test. Once the problem had a name, researchers needed a way to test ingredients for it, and the only model available was the rabbit ear. In the rabbit ear assay, an ingredient is applied repeatedly to the inside of a rabbit’s ear, and the follicles are then examined under a microscope for plugging. Rabbit ears were chosen because their large, sensitive follicles make plugging easy to see and measure. Kligman and Kwong refined the protocol in 1979, and the results were graded on a 0 to 5 scale, the scale still quoted on ingredient charts today.
Chapter three: the lists everyone copies, 1984 and 1989. James Fulton published the ingredient lists that most charts still copy. His 1984 paper in the Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology tested hundreds of ingredients and finished products using the rabbit ear method. His 1989 paper in the Journal of the Society of Cosmetic Chemists graded more than 200 cosmetic ingredients, each mixed at 10 percent in propylene glycol and applied to the inner ear of three rabbits, five days a week for two weeks. Fulton read his own scale in bands: 0 to 1 meant no significant plugging, 2 to 3 was borderline, and 4 to 5 meant an extensive increase, up to large comedones throughout the ear. He also noted the limitation himself, calling the rabbit ear assay not an ideal animal model but the best available at the time.
Chapter four: the corrections. The researchers themselves were the first to question the model. In 1982, Mills and Kligman built a human version of the test, and their finding was plain: the rabbit model is more sensitive than human skin, and substances that scored weakly comedogenic in the rabbit are probably safe for people, with the possible exception of acne prone ones. In 1996, Kligman reported that petrolatum and mineral oil, once called comedogenic under the original rabbit model, turned out to be false positives when the assay was tightened and tested on people with acne. That is why mineral oil is rated 0 on this site today. In 2006, Draelos and DiNardo published a re-evaluation whose central finding is the sentence every reader should remember: “Finished products using comedogenic ingredients are not necessarily comedogenic.” A 2025 review in JAAD Reviews concluded that rabbit ear results do not consistently predict what happens on human skin.
The scale is a historical reference, not a laboratory database. Almost every chart you find online traces back to the same two sources, Kligman’s work in the 1970s and Fulton’s lists from 1984 and 1989. Many ingredients people look up carry no published number at all, so a chart that assigns a confident number to one of them has invented that number. Treat any rating as a guide from an old, imperfect test.
What the Ratings Can and Cannot Tell You
The scale is useful, and this site is built on it. It is also limited. Here are the four limits that matter most in practice.
It tests one ingredient, not your product. Every rating came from a single ingredient on its own, usually at full strength or at a fixed 10 percent, applied to rabbit ears. Nobody uses a raw ingredient that way. A real product is a blend of many ingredients at different concentrations, and the blend behaves differently from any one line on its label. This is the point behind the 2006 finding quoted above: a finished product that contains a comedogenic ingredient is not necessarily comedogenic itself.
Concentration changes the number. A rating describes the dose as much as the ingredient. One often cited example is acetylated lanolin alcohol, reported at 4 to 5 at full strength and at 1 at 2.5 percent. The same ingredient, two very different numbers, depending on how much of it is there. That is why position on the label matters: an ingredient near the top is present in a meaningful amount, while the same ingredient near the bottom may be present at a fraction of a percent.
Rabbit skin is not human skin. Rabbit ear follicles are far more sensitive than human pores, which is why they were chosen for the test, and why the test overstates risk. The 1982 human model showed that several strong rabbit comedogens produced little or no clogging in people.
Your skin is a variable, not a constant. Oil production, skin type, climate, age, hormones, and the rest of your routine all change how a product behaves on you. Two people can use the same product and report opposite experiences, and both can be right. A rating is a population level signal from an old test, and your own skin’s response over two to four weeks of use is the only test that is actually about you.
What “Non-Comedogenic” on a Label Really Means
It sounds like a guarantee, and it is written to sound like one. It is not. In the United States, the FDA does not define or regulate the term “non-comedogenic”, and no agency certifies it. Brands apply the claim themselves, without a required standard test, and different brands mean different things by it. Some test their finished product on volunteers, some simply check that no ingredient in it is rated above 2, and some appear to apply it because the product feels light. The bottle does not tell you which one it is.
That does not make the claim useless, but it does change how to read it. Treat “non-comedogenic” as a brand’s own statement of intent, not as a test result. It is a useful signal that the brand was thinking about acne prone skin when it formulated the product, and products that carry it are, on average, a better place to start than products that do not. But it is not a promise, and it is not a substitute for reading the ingredient list. A product can carry the claim while containing high rated ingredients, and a product without the claim can be perfectly fine for your skin.
Two practical rules follow from this. First, check whether the claim is backed by anything you can see. Some brands publish their testing method or their ingredient rationale, and that transparency is worth something. A bare claim on the front of the bottle is worth much less. Second, always read the claim together with the ingredient list. If the list contains a 4 or 5 rated ingredient near the top, the front label claim should not override what the list says. Believe the formula, not the front of the bottle. Our non-comedogenic moisturizer guide applies this rule to real products.
How to Read a Label Like a Checker
You do not need a chemistry degree to read a label usefully. You need four habits, in order, and they take about a minute once you know them.
Read the first three to four ingredients
Ingredients are listed in descending order of concentration, so the first few names are effectively the formula. A high rated ingredient in the first three matters. Near the end, it is present in a small amount and matters much less.
Look up the ratings, not the marketing names
Ingredients appear under their INCI names, which are often unfamiliar. Jojoba oil is Simmondsia Chinensis Seed Oil, grapeseed oil is Vitis Vinifera Seed Oil, and shea butter is Butyrospermum Parkii Butter. Look each one up by its INCI name, or paste the whole list into a checker.
Judge the whole formula, not one line
One low rated ingredient does not make a product safe, and one high rated ingredient does not make it dangerous. What matters is the combination: how many high rated ingredients there are, where they sit, and whether the product is leave on or rinse off.
Patch test, then watch for two to four weeks
Apply the new product to one small area, such as one cheek, for several days before full face use. Then use it normally and watch for new closed comedones, the small bumps that appear before a breakout, over two to four weeks.
5 Common Mistakes People Make With Comedogenic Ratings
1. Judging one ingredient instead of the whole formula. This is the most common mistake, and it is the one this whole site exists to fix. A product is a blend. One low rated line does not rescue a blend full of high rated ingredients, and one high rated line does not condemn a blend that is otherwise gentle. Check every line.
2. Trusting the front label instead of the ingredient list. “Non-comedogenic”, “oil free”, and “dermatologist tested” are claims, not test results, and none of them is regulated the way the words suggest. Oil free products can still contain comedogenic esters and fatty alcohols. Read the back of the bottle, not the front.
3. Treating the rating as a verdict about your skin. A 4 does not guarantee a breakout, and a 0 does not guarantee clear skin. Ratings come from rabbit ears in the 1970s and 1980s. Use the rating to shortlist, then let your skin decide over two to four weeks.
4. Ignoring concentration and product type. An ingredient at 2.5 percent is not the same as the same ingredient at full strength, and a rinse off cleanser is not the same as a leave on cream. A high rated ingredient near the bottom of a cleanser is a small risk. Near the top of a night cream, it is a much bigger one.
5. Changing everything at once when you break out. When new congestion appears, people often replace their whole routine in one day, which makes it impossible to know which product was responsible. Change one product at a time and give it two to four weeks. That is slower than a full routine overhaul, and it is the only way to actually find the cause.
How to Check Your Own Products
Start with the ingredient list on the back of the bottle, not the claims on the front. Copy the full list, in order, and run it through the free Pore-Clogging Checker. It will flag every ingredient with a pore clogging risk, so you can see the whole formula at a glance instead of looking up one ingredient at a time. If you are seeing new congestion and you are not sure which product is responsible, our guide to signs your skincare is clogging your pores and the closed comedones guide can help you trace it. For the full reference behind the checker, see the full pore-clogging ingredients list and the comedogenic scale guide. To explore by family, the oils hub, the silicones hub, and the alcohols hub collect the site’s ingredient posts by category.
Check Your Product Before You Trust One Rating
A rating describes one ingredient. Your product is a whole formula. Paste the full ingredient list into the free Pore-Clogging Checker and see every pore clogging risk in seconds.
Check My Ingredients FreeFrequently Asked Questions
It means likely to clog pores. A comedogenic ingredient tends to block hair follicles and form comedones, which show up as blackheads when open and whiteheads when closed. The opposite word, non-comedogenic, means unlikely to clog pores under the conditions it was tested in.
It is a 0 to 5 scale that ranks ingredients by how likely they are to clog pores. A rating of 0 means no significant pore clogging in the test, 1 means very low, 2 to 3 means borderline, and 4 to 5 means a clear, reproducible clogging effect. The scale comes from tests done in the 1970s and 1980s, mostly on rabbit ears, and it describes single ingredients, not finished products.
No. A rating describes one ingredient at high concentration in a laboratory test, not a finished product on your face. Concentration, the rest of the formula, whether the product is rinse off or leave on, and your own skin all change the outcome. A product containing a comedogenic ingredient is not necessarily comedogenic itself.
It is the brand’s claim that the product is unlikely to clog pores. In the United States, the FDA does not define or regulate the term, and no standard test is required behind it, so brands apply it themselves. Treat it as a useful signal, not as a certification, and always read the ingredient list alongside it.
Most charts trace back to dermatologists Albert Kligman and Otto Mills, who named the problem of cosmetics causing comedones in their 1972 paper “Acne cosmetica”, and to James Fulton, who published widely copied ingredient lists in 1984 and 1989. The method was the rabbit ear assay, in which ingredients were applied to rabbit ears and plugging was graded 0 to 5. Later research showed the rabbit test overstates risk for human skin.
Look for new closed comedones, small bumps under the skin, or blackheads appearing where you use the product, usually within two to four weeks of starting it. Change one product at a time so you can identify the cause, and run the full ingredient list through the free checker to see which ingredients carry the highest ratings.
The Bottom Line
Comedogenic is a useful word with a real history, and now you know both. It means likely to clog pores and form comedones, and the 0 to 5 scale behind it ranks that tendency from 0, no significant clogging, to 5, a clear and reproducible effect. The numbers come from Kligman and Mills naming the problem in 1972 and from Fulton’s rabbit ear lists in 1984 and 1989, and later studies showed the test overstates risk for human skin and says nothing about a finished product on its own.
Use the word the way its history suggests: as a filter for shortlisting products, not as a verdict on your skin. Read the whole ingredient list, remember that concentration and product type change the meaning of a number, and let your skin decide over two to four weeks. And when the front of the bottle says “non-comedogenic”, believe the formula on the back, not the claim on the front.
This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. If breakouts persist or worsen, consult a qualified dermatologist.